• AC Home
  • News
  • Events
  • Quick Links
Austin College Logo

Sherman, Texas

Apply

Visit

MENU
  • 2022 Issue
    • From the President
    • … Worth a Thousand Words
    • Planet Hunters
    • Austin College Can Feel Like Home – For Everyone
    • The Joy of Giving While We’re Living
    • They’re Somethin’ in the Water
    • How Many Laps Make a Champion?
    • An UP and Coming Sport
    • Arts Prevail in Pandemic Times
    • How to Not Get Lost in the Woods
    • Healing in the Arts
    • From Ida Green to the LA Scene
    • ‘Roo Notes 2022
    • In Other Words
  • Issues
    • 2021 Issue
      • From the President
      • Seeing 20/20
      • On the Front Lines
      • A Broad Worldview Helps Doctors Face a Global Challenge
      • Finding A New Normal
      • Making A Way
      • This Family is All In
      • A Dream Realized
      • No One Plans for a Pandemic
      • Pastoring in 2020
      • CREATE at 5
      • Transformed: Student Success
      • An Expert in the House
      • A Voice for Good Health
      • ‘Roo Notes 2021
      • In Other Words
    • 2020 Issue
      • From the President
      • Global Life: ‘Roos Around the World
      • Good to Go
      • Just Keep Running
      • Pledged to the Public Good
      • Leaves Book and Tea Shop
      • Public Health Program Provides Popular Major and Minor
      • Power to the ‘Roos
      • ‘Roo Notes 2020
      • In Other Words
    • 2019 Issue
      • From the President
      • TWELVE
      • The Making of a Legend
      • One Legend’s Story
      • Sacred Expressions
      • Powering the Future
      • Fierce and Friendly
      • The Stories of the Stones
      • Truth in Art
      • ′Roo Notes 2019
      • In Other Words
    • Winter 2018
      • Snapshot
      • From the President
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • The President’s Home at Wood House
      • Roots
      • Home Team
      • 100 Years of Co-Education
      • President Steven P. O’Day
      • Giving to Prepare Future Servant Leaders
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • In Other Words
    • July 2017
      • Snapshot
      • Roots
      • From the Interim President
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • Home Team
      • The Adventure of a Lifetime
      • Au Revoir
      • The Momentum of Discovery
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • In Other Words
    • January 2017
      • From the President
      • For Love of the Game … and the Players
      • This Is Us – Diverse and United
      • Snapshot
      • Roots
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • Home Team
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • In Other Words
    • Winter 2016
      • From the President
      • Snapshot
      • Roots
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • Home Team
      • Living the Liberal Arts
      • At Home in the Rainforest
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • In Other Words
    • Summer 2015
      • From the President
      • Snapshot
      • Roots
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • Community Impact
      • Of Gratitude and Wonder
      • Home Team
      • Reimagining the Liberal Arts in A Digital Age
      • Medical Experience in Mexico
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • In Other Words
    • Spring 2014
      • From the President
      • Snapshot
      • Roots
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • Preventing Pandemic
      • Home Team
      • A Wild Semester
      • The Bottom Line is Greener
      • The Business of Learning
      • Blazing Trails
      • An IDEA Realized
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • In Other Words
    • Winter 2014
      • From the President
      • Snapshot
      • Roots
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • Making A Difference in the Natural World
      • The Mentor Advantage
      • ‘Roos Who Write
      • Storytellers’ Gift
      • Strategic Plan
      • Home Team
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • In Other Words
    • Summer 2013
      • From the President
      • Snap Shot
      • Roots: On the Road Again
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • Heard Around Campus
      • The Austin College Experience
      • Looking Back and Planning Ahead
      • Faculty Retirees Reflect
      • The Business of Food
      • Class of 2013 Takes on the World
      • A Legacy of Law
        • What is Pre-Law?
      • Dr. Kenneth Street
      • Making History
      • Home Team
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • In Other Words
    • Fall 2012/Winter 2013
      • From the President
      • Mission Around the Globe
      • My Summer of Learning
      • Views of the Outback
      • Our Identity
      • IDEA Center Challenge
      • Investing in Austin College
      • Snap Shot: Opening Convocation
      • Roots: Majestic Music
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • Home Team
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • In Other Words
    • Summer 2012
      • From the President
      • Detours to Adventure
      • At the Core of Excellence
      • Who Values Education? WE DO!
      • Sowing the Seeds
      • Banned, Buoyed, & Laureled:
      • A Lifetime In College
      • Snap Shot: Commencement
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • Heard Around Campus
      • Home Team
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • In Other Words
      • Roos for Roos
    • Spring 2012
      • From the President
      • Postcards from Abroad
      • Costa Rica Sisters
      • Texas Super Lawyers
      • An American in…Bucharest
      • My Internship in Congress
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • Home Team
      • ‘Roo Notes
    • Winter 2012
      • From the President
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • A Century of Science
        • Digging the Antarctic
        • Science in Everyday Life
        • Alumnus Integral To The Manhattan Project
        • Starry, Starry Nights
        • Telling Her Story
        • Celebrating the Unknown
        • A Look Back
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • In Other Words
    • Fall 2011
      • From the President
      • A New Year Begins
        • Meet the Class of 2015
        • Pieces of Home
        • Enrollee to Student
        • Freshman Legacies
        • The Summer Read
      • Gifts That Matter
        • Making Moments Matter
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • Home Team
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • Honor Roll of Donors
    • Summer 2011
      • From the President
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • Commencement Photos
      • The Many Faces of Success
      • Ghost Light
      • Time
      • In Full Bloom: Lives of Success
      • The Light Shines for Texas
      • Home Team
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • In Other Words
    • Spring 2011
      • From the President
      • From the Editor
      • JanTerm 2011
      • Commencement 2011
      • ACtivator Event #500
      • The Homesick Texan
      • Remembering Chase Gaddy
      • Along Grand Avenue
      • Home Team
      • ‘Roo Notes
      • In Other Words
  • Archives
  • Contact Us
Info For...
  • AC Home
  • News
  • Events
  • Quick Links
Home » Issues » Spring 2014 » In Other Words

In Other Words

Buck FilesReflections on Fifty Years in the Practice of Criminal law

By: Buck Files ’60

My fifty years in the practice of criminal law have been a great adventure: Always intellectually challenging; sometimes emotionally and physically draining; and, more fun than a child could have ever imagined. From prosecuting and defending cases before the courts-martial of the Marine Corps and Navy in Hawaii, Okinawa, and Vietnam to serving as first assistant criminal district attorney in Tyler to 44 years in the private practice of law, there has always been something just over the horizon that I have never seen before—and, on January 22, 2014, it was a trip to the Supreme Court of the United States.

The case was Paroline v. United States of America, et al. Almost six years ago, Chief Judge Leonard E. Davis of the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas appointed me to represent Mr. Paroline on a restitution issue arising out of a child pornography case. [Yes, even those who possess child pornography have a right under the Sixth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States to the effective assistance of counsel.]

“Amy” is the pseudonym for a victim of child pornography whose images were posted on the Internet. When two of these images were discovered on Mr. Paroline’s computer, “Amy’s” lawyer sought restitution from him in the amount of 3.4 million dollars.

I resisted “Amy’s” claims—urging that she had not suffered any losses as a result of Mr. Paroline’s conduct—and prevailed in the district court. When the Government and “Amy’s” lawyers appealed, I asked Stanley Schneider, a board-certified criminal appellate lawyer, to join me in the representation of Mr. Paroline. In its fourth written opinion, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reversed Judge Davis and ordered Mr. Paroline to pay the restitution sought by “Amy.”

Eventually, the Supreme Court agreed to hear Mr. Paroline’s case. Stanley presented our oral argument as I sat next to him with a copy of the joint appendix in front of me in order that I could give him a citation to the record if one of the Justices asked for it.

On April 23, the Supreme Court vacated the judgment of the Fifth Circuit and remanded the case to the district court for a second restitution hearing. Judge Davis will be required to award some restitution to “Amy”; however, Mr. Paroline will only be liable for his own conduct and not for the conduct of others. There will be no $3.4 million dollar award for two pictures. We won.

I would mention these two take-aways after watching the Supreme Court on three different days:

The Court Chamber, where the Justices hear oral arguments, could be described as cavernous, yet intimate. Measuring 82 by 91 feet and with a 44-foot-high ceiling, it is large enough to accommodate about 200 visitors in the public gallery and another 50 or so members of the Bar of the Supreme Court, who sit inside the rail and are closer to the Justices. When I was sitting at counsel table, I was only about 8 feet from Justices Thomas and Scalia.

The Justices are eager to pounce verbally upon the lawyers who are presenting arguments and to quiz them on their positions as stated in their written briefs. In some of the cases, the lawyers were able to speak for only about 30 seconds before being interrupted by one or more of the Justices. [We were fortunate to be given 60 long seconds.]

As a Golden ’Roo, I have been proud of my baccalaureate degree for more than 50 years. I first learned the value of an Austin College education when I mentioned that I was an Austin College graduate to an assistant dean at SMU’s School of Law. That was the end of the interview. He told me that I was admitted. I would have to sit for the Law School Admission Test, but that was only a formality.

The legal profession has changed dramatically over the past 50 years. There are now more lawyers in Dallas County (16,000+) than there were in Texas when I was admitted to practice 1963 (15,000+). Unfortunately, the cost of a law school education has escalated, and, nationally, there just are not enough jobs to go around.

Even so, I would still advise anyone who has dreamed of becoming a lawyer to pursue that dream if they understand that the legal profession is a servant profession. No one should ever become a lawyer for the purpose of getting rich. That can happen, but it should never be one’s primary focus. I am proud that Texas lawyers gave 2.42 million hours of their time in pro bono service last year to those who could not afford a lawyer. It has been my experience that the most respected lawyers are those who give back to the profession and help those who are poor and penniless.

In my 51st year of practice, do I intend to retire? No! If I did, I would always wonder who would have been the next person to walk through the door with some new and challenging issue.

Buck Files ’60 is finishing his 11th year as a member of Austin College’s Board of Trustees. He is the first Austin College alumnus to be elected president of the State Bar of Texas. He has received many honors in his professional career, including being elected to the Texas Criminal Defense Lawyers Association’s Hall of Fame and receiving a Lifetime Achievement Award from the Criminal Justice Section of the State Bar of Texas. Buck and his wife, Robyn McChesney Files ’62, have been married for 51 years and have two adult children, Jennifer Files Beerline ’89 and Trey Files.

The content of this column expresses the perspectives of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views, position, or policy of Austin College, its administrators, or its Board of Trustees.

GET IN TOUCH

903.813.2000
Austin College
900 N. Grand Ave.
Sherman, TX 75090

Contact Us

GET SOCIAL

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

GET LINKED

  • Quick Links
  • Human Resources
  • Campus Offices
  • Directory
  • Email

GET CONNECTED

Subscribe to Austin College E-Communication

Connect to AC

Copyright © 2022 - All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | Consumer Information | Site by thrive-logo